Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-based gene delivery vectors that preferentially express toxic genes in EBV-infected cells could be used to target EBV-positive
tumors for destruction. We have shown previously that the
cytosine deaminase (CD)
enzyme, which converts the
prodrug 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) into the toxic compound
5-fluorouracil efficiently kills EBV-positive cells in the presence of 5-FC, with a substantial bystander killing effect in vitro and in vivo. To identify the optimal
enzyme/
prodrug combination for treating EBV-positive
lymphomas, we have compared the effectiveness of the CD/5-FC combination with the
nitroreductase (NTR)/
CB1954 combination for killing EBV-positive B-cell lines. NTR metabolizes
CB1954 into an
alkylating agent that cross-links
DNA. When the CD gene or the NTR gene were transfected into two different EBV-positive B-cell lines in vitro, approximately 90% of cells were killed in a
prodrug-dependent manner, although the transfection efficiency was <5%. However, severe combined immunodeficient mouse
tumors containing either 30% or 100% of NTR-expressing
Burkitt lymphoma (Jijoye) cells were growth inhibited, but not cured, by treatment with intraperitoneal
CB1954 (20 mg/kg/day) for 10 days. These results suggest that the NTR/
CB1954 combination induces efficient bystander killing of EBV-positive B-cell lines in vitro but may not be as effective as the CD/5-FC combination for treating
B-cell lymphomas in vivo.