Controversy pervades the definition of adequate and optimal
vitamin D status. The Institutes of Medicine have recommended serum 25(
OH)D levels above 50 nmol/L based upon evidence related to bone health, but some experts, including the Endocrine Society and International
Osteoporosis Foundation, suggest a minimum serum 25(
OH)D level of 75 nmol/L to reduce the risk of falls and fractures in older adults. In a cross-sectional study, we compared
vitamin D status in people ≥75 years selected from four groups with a
frailty phenotype, combined with a control group free from serious illness, and who considered themselves completely healthy. Only 13% of the 169 controls were
vitamin D deficient (S-25(OH)D) < 50 nmol/L), in contrast with 49% of orthopedic patients with
hip fractures (n = 133), 31% of
stroke patients (n = 122), 39% of patients visiting the hospital's emergency department ≥4 times a year (n = 81), and 75% of homebound adult residents in
long-term care nursing homes (n = 51). The mean
vitamin D concentration of the healthy control group (74 nmol/L) was similar to a suggested optimal level based on physiological data and mortality studies, and much higher than that of many officially recommended cut-off levels for
vitamin D deficiency (<50 nmol/L). The present study provides a basis for planning and implementing public guidelines for the screening of
vitamin D deficiency and
vitamin D treatment for frail elderly patients.