[Burnout syndrome in pre-hospital and hospital emergency. Cognitive study in two cohorts of nurses].

Abstract

INTRODUCTION:

Burnout syndrome (BOS) associated with stress has been documented in health care professionals in many specialties. The emergency department and the pre-hospital healthcare services are highly stressful environments. Little is known about the BOS in critical care nursing staff. The objective of the study is to compare the incidence of BOS and its three domains, namely, emotional exhaustion, depersonalization and reduced professional accomplishment, in two cohorts of critical care nurses: a pre-hospital and a hospital emergency service.

METHODS:

A survey using a questionnaire (the Maslach Burnout Inventory-General Survey, MBI-GS), among nurses of two Italian emergency services has been performed: a hospital emergency service (HES, Emergency Department or "Pronto Soccorso") and a pre-hospital emergency service (PHES, territorial healthcare service or "Centrale Operativa 118").

RESULTS:

All 60 nurses surveyed (82% female) filled the questionnaires. BOS-related symptoms have been identified in at least 50% of the nurses in the HES: 50% suffered a medium-high emotional exhaustion, 75% had a medium-high depersonalization and 92.5% had a medium-high reduced professional accomplishment. Among the PEHS nurses, BOS-related symptoms have been identified in at least 60% of the respondents: 60% had a medium-high emotional exhaustion, 70% had a medium-high depersonalization and 95% had a medium-high reduced professional accomplishment. Moreover, the likelihood that a nurse has a severe BOS, that is at least one degree of high burnout or ≥2 degrees of medium burnout, is significantly higher in the group of the PHES than in the HES (90% vs 60%, p <0.02).

CONCLUSION:

At least two-thirds of critical care nursing staff had a severe BOS. The incidence of BOS appeared to be similar among PHES and HES nurses with a higher trend for the former. Further interventional studies are needed to investigate the determinants of BOS among critical care nurses and the potentially preventive strategies.

• Authors: Chiara Cicchitti, Giorgia Cannizzaro, Fabrizio Rosi, Roberto Maccaroni, Vincenzo G Menditto
• Journal: Recenti progressi in medicina (Recenti Prog Med) 2014 Jul-Aug Vol. 105 Issue 7-8 Pg. 275-80 ISSN: 0034-1193 [Print] Italy
• Vernacular Title: Il burnout in emergenza preospedaliera e ospedaliera. Indagine conoscitiva in due coorti di infermieri.
• PMID: 25072542 (Publication Type: Comparative Study, English Abstract, Journal Article)

Topics

• Adult
• Burnout, Professional (epidemiology, psychology)
• Cohort Studies
• Critical Care
• Depersonalization (psychology)
• Emergency Medical Services
• Female
• Humans
• Incidence
• Italy (epidemiology)
• Male
• Middle Aged
• Nursing Staff, Hospital (psychology, statistics & numerical data)
• Prospective Studies
• Surveys and Questionnaires