Thiazides are widely used to prevent recurrence of
calcium-containing
kidney stones. However, the recent NOSTONE trial reported no benefit of
hydrochlorothiazide on the composite outcome of symptomatic or radiologic recurrence. Higher doses (25 and 50mg daily) resulted in a decrease of radiologic recurrence, but no difference in symptomatic stones. Current guidelines preserve the use of
hydrochlorothiazide to patients with overt
hypercalciuria, while NOSTONE also included patients without
hypercalciuria. This might have underestimated the effect of
hydrochlorothiazide. While patients received dietary counseling, results suggest adherence was poor e.g. with respect to
oxalate and
salt consumption, possibly mitigating a potential beneficial hypocalciuric effect of
hydrochlorothiazide. Furthermore, previous studies that did show an effect of
thiazides on stone recurrence used higher doses. Thus, while
hydrochlorothiazide might not be effective in all patients with
calcium-containing
kidney stones, it should not be written off, as its efficacy in overt
hypercalciuria needs to be further elucidated.