Optimal Design of Clinical Trials Involving Persons with Disorders of Consciousness.

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Limited data exist regarding the optimal clinical trial design for studies involving persons with disorders of consciousness (DoC), and only a few therapies have been tested in high-quality clinical trials. To address this, the Curing Coma Campaign Clinical Trial Working Group performed a gap analysis on the current state of clinical trials in DoC to identify the optimal clinical design for studies involving persons with DoC.

METHODS:

The Curing Coma Campaign Clinical Trial Working Group was divided into three subgroups to (1) review clinical trials involving persons with DoC, (2) identify unique challenges in the design of clinical trials involving persons with DoC, and (3) recommend optimal clinical trial designs for DoC.

RESULTS:

There were 3055 studies screened, and 66 were included in this review. Several knowledge gaps and unique challenges were identified. There is a lack of high-quality clinical trials, and most data regarding patients with DoC are based on observational studies focusing on patients with traumatic brain injury and cardiac arrest. There is a lack of a structured long-term outcome assessment with significant heterogeneity in the methodology, definitions of outcomes, and conduct of studies, especially for long-term follow-up. Another major barrier to conducting clinical trials is the lack of resources, especially in low-income countries. Based on the available data, we recommend incorporating trial designs that use master protocols, sequential multiple assessment randomized trials, and comparative effectiveness research. Adaptive platform trials using a multiarm, multistage approach offer substantial advantages and should make use of biomarkers to assess treatment responses to increase trial efficiency. Finally, sound infrastructure and international collaboration are essential to facilitate the conduct of trials in patients with DoC.

CONCLUSIONS:

Conduct of trials in patients with DoC should make use of master protocols and adaptive design and establish international registries incorporating standardized assessment tools. This will allow the establishment of evidence-based practice recommendations and decrease variations in care.

• Authors: Sung-Min Cho, Chiara Robba, Michael N Diringer, Daniel F Hanley, J Claude Hemphill, Janneke Horn, Ariane Lewis, Sarah L Livesay, David Menon, Tarek Sharshar, Robert D Stevens, James Torner, Paul M Vespa, Wendy C Ziai, Marcus Spann, Raimund Helbok, Jose I Suarez, Curing Coma Campaign and its contributing members
• Journal: Neurocritical care (Neurocrit Care) (Aug 03 2023) ISSN: 1556-0961 [Electronic] United States
• PMID: 37535178 (Publication Type: Journal Article)
• Copyright: © 2023. Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature and Neurocritical Care Society.