Abstract | BACKGROUND:
Malaria rapid diagnostic tests (mRDTs) are the preferred option for programmatic deployment. AIMS: There are numerous mRDTs on the Nigerian market and there is a need to guide practitioners on the relative performance of the commonly used brands of mRDT in Nigeria. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: The performance of three commonly used Histidine-Rich-Protein-2-based mRDTs (SD-Bioline™, Carestart™ and Paracheck-Pf™) against microscopy of Giemsa stained blood and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was evaluated among 190 febrile under-5 children in Ibadan, Nigeria. We calculated the sensitivity, specificity, predictive values, accuracy, and agreements. RESULTS: There were 53.2% males. The prevalence of malaria parasite by microscopy was 46.8% and 57.9% by PCR. Malaria parasite detection by SD-Bioline™ was 60.5%, Carestart™: 60.0% and Paracheck-Pf™ 60.0%. Using microscopy as the gold standard, the sensitivities of SD-Bioline™, Carestart™ and Paracheck-Pf™ mRDT were 97.8%, 96.7% and 97.8% respectively while the specificities were 73.0%, 72.0% and 74.0% respectively. Using PCR as the gold standard, the sensitivity for both SD-Bioline™ and Paracheck-Pf™ was 85.5% and for CareStart was 84.6% while the specificity of SD-Bioline™, Carestart™, and Paracheck-Pf™ was 73.8%, 72.4%, and 75.0% respectively. The test accuracy was 81.0% for both SD-Bioline™ and Paracheck-Pf™ and 80.0% for Caresatrt™. The kappa coefficient of agreement between PCR and each of SD-Bioline™, Carestart, ParaCheck™ and microscopy was 0.597, 0.578, 0.609 and 0.739 respectively. CONCLUSION: The performance of the three mRDTs is a proof that any of the three is suitable for use in the diagnosis of malaria in the southwest of Nigeria.
|
Authors | A E Orimadegun, R I Funwei, O S Michael, O O Ogunkunle, J A Badejo, F I Olusola, O Agede, O E Anjorin, I O Ajayi, A S Jegede, O Ojurongbe, C O Falade |
Journal | Nigerian journal of clinical practice
(Niger J Clin Pract)
Vol. 24
Issue 4
Pg. 496-504
(Apr 2021)
ISSN: 1119-3077 [Print] India |
PMID | 33851670
(Publication Type: Journal Article)
|
Chemical References |
|
Topics |
- Child
- Diagnostic Tests, Routine
- Female
- Histidine
- Humans
- Malaria
(diagnosis)
- Malaria, Falciparum
(diagnosis, epidemiology)
- Male
- Microscopy
- Nigeria
- Plasmodium falciparum
- Polymerase Chain Reaction
- Sensitivity and Specificity
|